My Photo
Name:
Location: San Francisco, California, United States

An appropriation-friendly, image-rich, experimental research library. Independent and open to the public.

Saturday, February 18, 2006

Google Book Search treats government documents as copyrighted material

Playing with Google Book Search and finding many excellent surprises, including a whole slew of historically valuable government documents that appear to be scanned from libraries at Harvard and Stanford. I've always felt Google is on the way to creating an excellent searchable keyword index of monographic material, even if their online books don't behave like books (as of now, they cannot be downloaded, printed, cataloged, cited, individual pages can't be referred to, and there is no available list or catalog of what books are online).

But there's one really distressing thing happening here. U.S. government documents are, by law, in the public domain, as they are produced with taxpayer funds. The only exceptions to public domain status are a limited number of cases in which private contractors have been hired to produce certain materials to which they retain copyright. But what Google seems to be doing is treating govdocs published after 1923 in the same way as they are treating non-government materials -- as potentially copyrighted material. This is unnecessarily cautious, and what it means is that only "snippets" are available and the document remains unreadable.

Take a look at an example or two:

Here's what appears to be Volume I of Violations of Free Speech and Rights of Labor, the famous LaFollette Committee hearings on industrial espionage, strikebreaking and other unsavory weapons used against labor in the 1930s. If you click on the link, you'll just see snippets. This is a public domain document published in 1936 by the Government Printing Office.

Here are published hearings before the Judiciary Committee in 1974 on the subject of "Warrantless Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance." This is another public domain document that seems highly relevant at this moment.

And here's one volume of a large collection of Senate hearings investigating the munitions industry, probably sometime in the 1930s (the Google "metadata" shows no date).

By contrast, here's a pre-1923 government publication that is readable in full through Google's book reader: Benton MacKaye's fascinating report, Employment and Natural Resources (1919). MacKaye, as many of you may know, was the visionary planner and early "network thinker" who came up with the idea for the Appalachian Trail. It's great to see this report online.

I found dozens of govdocs that were just presented as "snippets," and there are probably thousands more. I've written Google Book Search to ask about what's going on. The real question, as I see it, is whether they are being overcautious (which the 1923ish cutoff would suggest) or worried that making complete page images of government documents easily available might somehow be a threat to their business model. Either way, it's not a good thing to treat government documents as if they were copyrighted material.

(Rick, speaking in his individual capacity)

UPDATE: I've heard from people who may be in a position to know something about this issue. They remind me that many Congressional hearings reprint copyrighted information (e.g., news articles and excerpts from publications). Although the copyright situation involving these reprinted extracts is uncertain, Google is proceeding with extreme caution. I haven't yet checked to see whether post-1923 govdocs containing no reprinted material are restricted from full access. If this is indeed the case, it's unfortunate that negative reaction to Google Book Search has put them in such a defensive position.

FURTHER UPDATE: The embedded copyrights issue doesn't seem to apply. It appears that many other post-1923 government documents are presented only as "snippets." Examples:

The GPO Monthly Catalog for July 1934, a "pure" government document containing only government-generated content

Laws Relating to Shipping and Merchant Marine (1927)

United States Government Manual (1971-72)

and Copyright Law of the United States (date not indicated).


It looks as if Google is definitely considering all post-1923 works under copyright.

11 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

The larger issue is how Google will treat post 1923 public domain books. I've heard stats that in the 20's around 90 percent of works were not renewed. Is Google going to do a copyright search for these works?

akb

9:38 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for those examples Rick. There are copyrighted materials imbedded within many govpubs (hearings...) -- including journal articles and other copyrighted material included within appendices and such -- and I think this shows that the publishers have succeeded in making google extremely wary about copyright to the detriment of the public.

You may be interested in my post about google books search. It seems clear to me at least that google book project will be extremely valuable, but that it WILL NOT become the defacto digital archive to public information and WILL NOT replace libraries as repositories of information and knowledge. Libraries should be extremely careful about moving their govpubs to off-sight storage under the mistaken notion that they will now be available in GBP.

jrj

1:45 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Several of us at the University of Michigan have contacted Google about the copyrighted treatment of federal documents. As I understand it, Google is being just a little bit cautious but actively consulting with its legal team over making the full text available to the public online.

gy

12:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

the grim reaper pointing at duncan rouleau and his family, like jonah weiland, michael hull, Reverend S. M. Scott, Rebekah bekah girl, Lee Grady, James C. Moberg, Gabriel Leonard, Paula Cavu, Aubrey Malphurs, Timothy Fish, Stephanie Edge, John Vlautin, Roy Sauzek, Ron King , Dan Jessen, Ben Arment, nolan bobbitt, gavin proter Robby mac, mary nella mclaughlin, ann marie, Gerry Mc Daniel, dave wilson, todd callender, Matthew Littleton, Amos R. Albright, Sean von Tagen, pastor wally, paul wally, Laurie Hirata, Barbara O'Brien, John Strong, Chris Forbes, robert gillen, Keith Page, Kathryn Aragon, Paul R. Mitchell, Mike Oppenheimer, dchandler, dchandler's, drew chandler, Daniel Brown, Steve Stephens, Gautam Godhwani, Brad Edwards, Ronald V. Duncan, Carroll Marr, Mike Slaughter, Donald W. Ebelt, Jr, Rich DuBose, andy jayne, Jayne, President Joseph Castleberry, jim null from medsend, Andy, Jayne, Ken Himes, D.Min., CKYT Radio 13's sistermoonshine, wolfie_and_kansas, wolfie, kansas, sistermoonshine13@hotmail.com, Sam Huddleston, Tim Colovos, Ken Godevenos, renee delorenzo, sistermoonshine13, Thomas Rickert, of the last-fm, Kurt McClung, sabrina mckenzie, Paula M. Cavu, Rizza Legaspi, James Mills, Carl Schenck, utubia1party, BARB BALLARD, snygman, snygman Carregando, Mike Bickle, Yvonne Platts, john wright, Rick Frye, Paul and Agnès Sanders, Lynda Freeman, Dora Dueck, Rev. Dr. John H. Thompson, Sr, John Theis, Ali Klees, Duane Ray, Terry Pratchett, Darlene Zschech, Lou Engle, Nadia Dronova, valoria cheek, Rev Tripp, Gifts from God Ministries, Sue Shaw, margaret marcuson, Ronnie Floyd, Woodley, Matt Woodley, Julie, Eddy Hall, Jennifer Gale, Thomas Reddinger, Ms. Garnet, Ginny Olson, Diane Elliot, Mike Work, Howard Culbertson of soutern nazarene university, Senyum Sayang, Dana Reardon, Robert Tulip, Karl Kobrock, dan burrell, Mark Inouye, Bill Donahue, Terry Bates, Kathy Lefler, Jason Boyett , Pinto, Francisco's pastor bryan article, BEN BINGER, Carl Nash, Deb Wilkins, John Godson, Misja Pielgrzym, Kosciol Bozy w Chrystusie, Jim Coons, Chris Beach, ken hammonds, John Bjorge, shaun groves, Jack Hammans, marynella mclaughlin, Curt Swindoll, CEO, brian m. Albrecht, Marilyn Strauss, Bethany Yeo, Wayne Jacobsen, John Klees and Micki Cabaniss, David W. Henderson, Tim and Daphne Stapleton, shawn brown, nelson osamu hayashida, Scottie May, Dayton, Ed, ed dayton, Dominic & Nomi Sola's Michelle M. , Larry Crabb, Childress, Jeffrey, Craig Rucin, Michelle M, Wilson L. Deaton, David Mackin, Danny Stone, Fred Smith, President, The Gathering, Dr. Kenneth Boa, Mark Peterson, Bonnie Brann, frank rosensterndoug , Jay & Linda Threadgill, small, ismail kadare, janetmck, arron shutt, george doran, elizabeth shea, Ken Kelly, andy shaw, tom beland, kenley darling, quinling harlequin, Fred Knoll, Derek Lynas, david shapiro, Lynsae Harkins, FunkyGreenJerusalem, Dalarsco, cecil pennyton, joe lalich, dave karlotski, daugan, Amanda at Mama sings: Leaving Egypt, Steve F., justin daniels davis, john mark pool, Shawn brown, Kermit Netteburg, Eugene Oh, tim baker, Josh McDowell, Erik A. Olson, Don Rose, YWAM Latvia, jose alvarez, dee finney, antonia vladimirova, Jay Ashcraft , Leroy Freeman, carla educar, katie bazor, Carl Creasman, andrew deal, Ron Klabunde, Ambrose Roasa, Peter Fitchamanda dee, Mitch Anderson, Tim Schmoyer, jeff dee, reverend jeremy taylor, d.min, christina marie sanford, jean patrick charrey got Fazile Zahir got Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR? Spó³ka, greg titus, BaldySlaphead, Max Lopez, Evan McBroom, mike kenney, Douglas L. Fagerstrom, Rick Frye, brian, bill of the massive bri, Bruce Ryskamp, lawrence forman, micheru mathys, dana tillusz, George Tramountanas, John Lawry, John Jaszcz, and Randy Williams, JK Rowling, Nakul Chander, Wally Schmidt, Kiel Nunn, nick field, Heuva, michael doran, erick Fazile Zahir, Pastor Erick Waukegan, IL
youth ministry liaison for the North Central Conference of the Free Methodist, Greg Bayaca and The Rev. Gerry Engnan, don and Linden Petrin, Bert McCumsey, Paul Meier, Chris Nelson, Alicia, Sung Hyun Um, John H. Thompson, Trond Hundstuen, Jim Case, Karen L. Schmidt, Andrey Stepanyuk , Dan Seidman, Tim Howey , Greg & Sherry, Dr. R. Mark Beadle, blaine motsinger, Jerry Frear, Konstantin Ternianov, janet mcknight, Laurie Behncke, Heuva, Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR? Spóka, Brad Gee, Senior Pastor,
Fazile Zahir richard starkings, joe kelly, mike hull, cesar gonzalez, Hugh T. Blevins, Jr., daniel kaps, SCHRAMM, Richard, Dean Galvin, Lusine Safaryan, diana hughey, Thom S. Rainer, Ronald L Hawkins, wendi hammond, helen calder, Bob McQueary, Richard E. Lauersdorf, brian hirt, bill hamon Zespó³ Doradców Gospodarczych, “TOR? Spó³ka, Dann Pantoja, robert winer, paul dixon, rohn price, diana hughey, Mhada Oshiwara, Andheri West, dan kaps, Nicholson, Roy, john m. bailey, Richard L. Reising, phil at vibrance in ministry, Julie Lautt, Henry Doorn, Jack Ellis, Gordon Miller, dave at faf@ag.org, Jay Mooney, Pastor Ellen, Michael Cork, John Yates, Richard F. Myers, Willam Murray, larry clow, Darrell G. Young, david reagan, Paul Sang, Valoria L. Cheek, thom s. rainer, eric geiger, Sabrina McKenzie Ministries, Larry Frank, renewla, Alex Choi
, rex frieze, kiddos galore, Alissa Bertsch, Walt Mueller, Jay Mooney, Diamond Management Consultants dave moon, Chandigarh Express, Pete Widdop, Annette LaPlaca, Delbert Enns, Rev. Dr. John H. Thompson, Sr, President, scott morton, John Drage, Pastor Bill Dornbush, Duane Ray, Ali Klees, Lawrence McCorkle Gill’s family, CP-TEL, Jason Boyett, Stephen Felts, Kathy Lefler,Dr. James W. Dyer, Jr., Kathy Schaeffer, Joyce Strong, Alan Fox, John Wray, Matt Jones, John Engels, kobe holler, Jeremy Camp, Chris Bush, ARMEN BERJIKLY like Sabrina McKenzie, Frank Braun, Julia A. Spohrer, rick long, Shusaiyuan Biz, David Bearden, Al Jourgensen, Rick Warren, Stefanie Farrone, Len Kageler, Arthur Cherrie, R. Paul Stevens, Charles R. Shumate, Michael & Karen McDonald, Pat Verbal, Dr. mike Murdock, Phillip Butler, Ross Slaughter , Howard Culbertson, James L. Benedict, Michael Bartley, Carole Louise Sawatzky is lost, cut off saith God, John Freeman, Ed Young, Rick Cruse, Dr. Steve Stephens, Elizabeth Cullen, Joyce Strong, Annette LaPlaca, dr. kara powell, Matt Woodley and Julie Woodley, Barry St. Clair, Chad Zaucha, Rick Warren, B.A. Cooley, Susan Riddle, Micah Andrews, scottie may, beth posterski, catherine stonehouse, linda cannell, Brian Kluth, Doug Diehnelt, Jennifer Gale, Paul McDonald, Eric Brass, JEANIE STANLEY, Mr. William Stevens, Safiyah Marshay, India Arie, jeanie r. stanley,
Luke Brouillette, Doug Haugen and Andrew Bosch, Rev. Dr. M. Hadwin Fischer, Matthew Nowlin, howard culbertson, Paula M. Cavu and Dr Gavin Porter PhD, dr. sheikh muszaphar and dr. faiz Dann Pantoja, Lee Dodd, brandon teer, Hurckman, Tom R. Harper, amerintia human, Lee Gugliotto, Ph.D., David Neal, brittany hill, Pastor Billy Joe Daugherty, lemar mast, Rev. Stephen Reed, Steve Angello, Terry & Donna Keith, Heber E. Rast Jr., matt cario, Belinda Wright, Henri Nouwen, RANDALL K. KNUTSON, carmen joyce, Sr. Pastor Don Underwood, Ernestine Youngs, Dr. Rodney A. Harrison, Chris Alford, bruce marchiano, Julia A. Spohrer, Brian Kluth, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Rev. Jos?Zito Oliveira and Mrs. Zilta Rocha de Carvalho Oliveira Art Beals, Alisha Beverly, reiki music, lindsay greer, luke greer, Dennis Edwards, Chris Forbes, Keith Page, ginny olson, diana elliot, and mike work, dave wilson, HB London and Neil B. Wiseman, Elizabeth House, josh hunt, Dennis Klussman, Wszelkie prawa zastrzeżone, Jimmy Williams, Michael Ward, sunnysnet, sunnysweb, Dr. R. Mark Beadle of SEVENSTAR ACADEMY, michele rickett, sisters in service, Mike and Kerry Clarensau, VERLIN BYERS, glenn gerdes, wayne muirhead, ted Engstrom, krista petty, Tim Boyd, Vic Kennett, Sr. M. Dolorosa, R. Kent Hughes, Richard Woughter, SeLahGirl, Daniel Brown, Eddy Hall, Gary & Carrie Espeseth, Mark Warnock, Deborah F. Jenks, sue mickey, Clifton Eshbach and Pastor Conrad B., mn church planting, Ruth Ann, kobe aka skreetpreacha, Jenny Duff, COREY, WAYNE, DAN, Jeri Rose, Dr. Stephen J. Carter, Rob Martini, Pastor Mark Burch, Dwyndl, Lori, Noah & Bayley Nelms, Steve Roesch, Nicholas Wolterstorff, The Rev. LeRoy L. Carlson, jared cramer, Paul and Agnès Sanders, Dave & Dawn Bovenmyer, Dennis Klussman, tim chan, Kimberley Ward, Kip Gilts, Sheila Swafford, Jane Fitzjerrell, Nilson Kibbey, kimberly giarrusso, Aleathea Dupree, Joseph Boerman, Bob Cramer, Denise Knight, Rich Stone, RICK KINDSCHI, ron c. scott noble, keith johnson, sistermoonshine13 who is Joel Tao, these are all the children of satan's high priest wizard jeremy taylor of starr king school of ministry, they all stole the God spoken created name ministry of dreams, to ruin God's servant of his salvation and God is ruining them and makes them run to remove like d.min jeremy taylor m.a. will, tell satan taylor watch his soothsaying career end and then he laughs but removes ministry of dreams, kathryn taylor loved till ruint then left, mock her, till death do us part, they are witchs like jim garrison, rebecca ann parker, gina halpern, richard rosen, susan rosen, wizard amy brucker, they, most, posted his article, or stole, the name ministry of dreams to make prophet fall, all release ruint, this is duncan rouleaus family, they want Gods servant to fall,

4:49 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Seeking Alumni in Psychology/Psychiatry
1980
Name: Karen L. Fagerstrom (Glenn)
Approx. age: 55
From: Rockford, Illinois

5:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

seeking:

Karen Lou Fagerstrom (Glenn)
Age Approx. 55
Student in 1980
Home: Rockford, Illinois

5:04 AM  
Blogger george said...

The google book is used to very take people. For this book is online take in US people.

-------------------

george

car auctions

8:04 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

buy wow goldAsesor ProfessionalUruguayProfessionalbuy wow goldOfficeLinksNotice

2:02 PM  
Anonymous Gold Guide for World of Warcraft said...

good post :)

12:02 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Updating a link from comment #2. my post about google books search is on a blog that has gone offline. Luckily, the internet archive's wayback machine collected it and you can read it here.

That was 2 years ago, but the issues with google's scans of public domain govt information remain. I truly believe that anything submitted to a govt hearing, regardless of its copyright status, should automatically, as part of the public discourse, be in the public domain.

8:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am grateful to you for this great content.
lezbiyenler
lezbiyen
lez

3:16 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home